Amazon sent me a broken Apple Watch — twice. Now it won’t accept my return

Photo illustration by Christopher Elliott

Shirley Justice’s Apple Watch, which she ordered from Amazon, doesn’t work. Neither does the replacement watch Amazon sends her. Now Amazon won’t take back the replacement watch. Can she get some justice?


I ordered an Apple Watch on Prime Day from Amazon. It did not work, so I returned it to Amazon for a replacement. The replacement watch also didn’t work, and I also sent it back. I returned each watch in the original Apple packaging and using the return label provided by Amazon.

★ Got a consumer problem? Here’s how to get free help.

Something went awry with my last return. Amazon won’t acknowledge the returned item or issue a $329 refund. I’m caught in an email loop trying to reach an account specialist to appeal this decision.

I’m concerned about Amazon’s comments in the emails. It says they have discarded an “incorrect” item but are “unable to provide detailed information about the returns.”

I sent an email to two Amazon executives listed on your site, but they bounced. Can you help me get my refund? — Shirley Justice, Smyrna, Del.


Amazon should have sent you a working Apple Watch. But to have it send you a second broken watch — well, that’s exceedingly rare.

I reviewed your paper trail, in which you describe the problem. You contacted Apple Support, and after two hours of troubleshooting, a technician told you Amazon had possibly sent you a refurbished watch that never worked correctly. Hmm.

I’m sorry about the bouncing email addresses. Amazon has had some organizational changes recently. My research team is constantly trying to find working email addresses, but executives often like to hide from their customers. We’ve updated the Amazon management contacts on our consumer advocacy site. I also publish a free guide on how to fix your consumer problem that you might find helpful.

★ Travel better! Subscribe to Elliott Confidential, our email newsletter.

So what kind of loop were you stuck in? It looks like Amazon had flagged your account for frequent returns, although it’s unclear if the returns were for this watch or for a previous purchase. It looks like you sent your last purchase back to Amazon after Apple stopped offering the watch through Amazon.

When you checked the status of the return, you received strange answers. Sample: “Although we understand your concern, unfortunately we are unable to provide detailed information about the returns you are looking for.” In other words, Amazon wouldn’t say if it had or hadn’t received your last watch, even though UPS had tracked the package to Amazon and registered it as delivered.

You’re right — you were stuck in some kind of loop. The only way out of that loop is to go over the heads of the representatives (or more likely, the bots generating these emails). I think the Amazon executive contacts would have worked — if we had been able to keep up with Amazon’s organizational changes.

I contacted Amazon on your behalf. The next day, you received an email from a real person at Amazon. “We have requested a refund of $329 to the original payment method used on your order. You will be able to see the refund on your respective account statement in the next four to six business days.”

Christopher Elliott is the founder of Elliott Advocacy, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization that empowers consumers to solve their problems and helps those who can’t. He’s the author of numerous books on consumer advocacy and writes weekly columns for King Features Syndicate, USA Today, Forbes and the Washington Post. He also publishes the Elliott Report, a news site for consumers, and Elliott Confidential, a critically acclaimed newsletter about customer service. If you have a consumer problem you can’t solve, contact him directly through his advocacy website. You can also follow him on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn, or sign up for his daily newsletter. This article originally appeared on under the headline Amazon sent me a broken Apple Watch — twice. Now it won’t accept my return.



Award-winning author, journalist and consumer advocate. Read me in USA Today, the Washington Post and via King Features. Email me at

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Christopher Elliott

Award-winning author, journalist and consumer advocate. Read me in USA Today, the Washington Post and via King Features. Email me at